Hello dear
Welcome To Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan
At Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan, we blend rich tradition with local flavor. Nestled in San Juan Capistrano, this pizzeria has quickly established itself as a top destination for authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza. Our passion for quality shines through in every dish, from the homemade marinara sauce simmered with the finest tomatoes and herbs to our extensive menu featuring pastas, sandwiches, and wraps. Guests rave about the vibrant ambiance and attentive service, making it perfect for families and gatherings. With a rotating selection of craft beers and a commitment to diverse dietary needs, Selma's is more than just a pizzeria—it's an experience to savor.
About
Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan
Welcome to Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of San Juan Capistrano, California. Located at 31781 Camino Capistrano #201, this establishment has quickly garnered a reputation for dishing out some of the finest Chicago-style pizzas in the nation, despite not having once called the Windy City home.
At Selma's, the focus is on beautifully crafted pizzas that pay homage to the rich traditions of Chicago cuisine. Whether you're a fan of the classic deep dish or prefer the crispness of a thin crust, there's something to tantalize every pizza lover's palate. The Cheese & Tomato options—available in small, medium, and large—showcase premium whole milk mozzarella, allowing diners to customize their creations with an array of fresh toppings. Prices start at a reasonable US$12.20, making it accessible for all.
- Deep Dish Variety: The layers of cheese and toppings create a luscious flavor experience that has left customers like Len Paskus claiming it's the best Chicago deep dish pizza available.
- Artisan Pizzas: Venture into the unique with options such as the Popeye—featuring olive oil, spinach, goat cheese, and more—offering an artistry that appeals to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike.
- Gourmet Salads: The Buck’s BBQ Chicken Chopped Salad is particularly noteworthy, serving as a perfect complement to the pizza experience with its fresh mix of ingredients and BBQ ranch dressing.
But it’s not just the food that shines at Selma's. The ambiance is described as chill and welcoming, ideal for family gatherings or a night out with friends. Whether you're enjoying a game on the TV or taking in the lovely outdoor dining area, the vibe is perpetuated by a friendly staff, with servers like Dino making it a memorable experience. Guests like Jacob Garcia and Ari Sanchez rave about both the excellent service and the beer selection, which pairs perfectly with any meal.
For those planning special events, like Mindy Papazian, the restaurant offers private dining options that cater to unique needs while assuring an exceptional dining experience from start to finish.
In a world where pizza can often disappoint, Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room effortlessly brings a slice of Chicago to California, making it a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in quality pizza and fantastic dining experience. With its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, it’s no surprise that they're praised not only for their food but for creating a warm, inviting atmosphere that keeps people coming back for more.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Selma's Chicago Pizzeria San Juan Capistrano I suspect this restaurant has never operated in Chicago, but, currently they make the best Chicago deep dish pizza in the nation. I grew up in Chicago. A very long time ago, when I was 10 years old, some new restaurant, that everybody was talking about, called gee or danios opened. We walked there from our house. It was a tiny, packed, "hole in the wall" restaurant, without a ..., serving the absolute best deep dish pizza we had ever tasted. The rumor was, they put ... in their sauce. Nobody cared, it was by far the best deep dish in Chicago. Forward, 50 years later, it has franchised a long time ago,the pizza they serve is... Then visited Selma's "Chicago"pizzeria in multiple locations in California. From my Google searches, Selma's has never sold a pizza in Chicago. But, as of today they make the best example of Chicago deep dish. Much, much better than current Chicago staples. A quiet, unassuming restaurant serving the best Chicago deep dish in the nation .... in California. ”
“ Great pizza, excellent ambiance, and a very tending staff. Can't ask for more. ”
“ Great pizza and great beer selection! Shout out to Dino, he provided excellent service and recommended the fries which were amazing ”
“ We're big Selma's fans. Chill pizza joint with good bar food, salads, sandwiches and options to accommodate all diets such as vegan, gluten free and keto. Parking is usually pretty easy in the structure around the corner, but you may have to park on the roof. Good options for families and big parties. Nice outdoor dining options, rotating taps and sports always playing. Servers are always pleasant. Pizza can be expensive because of the quality ingredients and crust options. Accepts all credit cards. If you find this post helpful please like! ”
“ I reserved the private room at SJC for my son’s rehearsal dinner (Nov 2023) and couldn’t have been more pleased with our experience. From reserving the room, to picking the food, to help with my set-up, the staff..everything was on point. Great people. Very reasonably priced and food was delicious! I highly recommend them. ”
“ Gotta rave about this restaurant. I have been trying to find good Chicago style deep dish pizza in California for 23 years and found it here, quite by accident. My Wife and I both are originally from Chicago, and we are very familiar with what makes a good, no, great deep dish pizza. This place got it right! We split a small size, with only Italian sausage (good quality sausage too), we started off with the regular size Italian chopped salad. This was plenty of food for us both and probably too much for a couple of average eaters. The staff was courteous and helpful, very professional. The restaurant was clean and very pleasant, with windows open to the sidewalk and an outdoor patio. There is a full bar which features a happy hour menu. The restrooms were well maintained, clean and fully stocked. Service was quick. The price for all this was not bad either! We had two iced teas as well, and the bill, with tax, came out to just 36.96! About what you would pay for a couple of burgers in a casual dining restaurant. All in all, I, we highly recommend this restaurant and will be coming back again. ”
“ Selma's Chicago Pizzeria is an incredible restaurant. There are multiple locations around the area. This particular one requires a paid parking lot, but the other ones are available with free parking. The staff here is great. The menu is extensive. Their beer selection is wonderful. Bring your entire family and enjoy their food. They show sports on their televisions in the bar area. They do have rooms that are available for private events if you are so inclined. At least one of the owners is a family man, and that goes a long way in my book. ”
“ The sausage had fennel and slightly spicy and was the same sausage you would get in Chicago. Normally Chicago pizza has the toppings underneath the cheese and it's cut into squares though not triangles. They use a butter crust that had a nice depth of flavor so it was probably fermented a day or so. Usually you need to have the dough rise on its own to get that flavor. However having the veggies on top kept the crust nice and crispy on the bottom. Def will be trying the deep dish next time. ”